Fiber Cement Siding vs Vinyl: Which One Holds Up the Best?

In 2018, the most common siding on new homes was vinyl and stucco. Stucco is a type of cement siding that continues to be popular alongside vinyl. If you are considering a new exterior look, you should consider the differences that both siding options provide.

Read our guide on fiber cement siding vs. vinyl.

Fiber Cement Siding vs. Vinyl

To figure out which siding is right for you, you have to understand what is fiber cement siding and vinyl siding. When it comes to fiber cement siding vs. vinyl, there are basic comparisons to consider.

Fiber cement siding is made up of a mix of wood and cement that creates long boards or shingles. It gets directly attached to the home using nails.

In comparison, vinyl siding is made from PVC which is a plastic material. It gets affixed to the home’s exterior that leaves room for expansion and contract of changing temperatures. These basic comparisons should get taken into consideration along with these other factors.

Cost

The cost to install fiber cement siding tends to be more expensive than vinyl siding. The average cost of vinyl siding installation is around $200 per 100 square feet. For the same area, fiber cement costs $300 per 100 square feet to install.

Not only can you save money by installing vinyl siding over fiber cement siding, but you can also save money in the long run. Fiber cement siding problems that could cost you more money later include needing recaulking and painting. These siding problems may not seem like a big deal but can cost you more than you are willing to spend.

Maintenance

Another consideration to make when choosing fiber cement siding vs. vinyl is the maintenance requirements. As mentioned, when installed, fiber cement siding needs to get caulked and painted. However, you can opt for a prepainted version if you are willing to spend extra money.

Vinyl siding needs nothing before or after installation. While you will need to repaint and recaulk fiber cement siding, vinyl siding requires little to no effort throughout its lifetime.

Durability

Whether we are talking about Hardiplank vs. vinyl siding or stucco vs. vinyl siding, the durability of each matter. When compared to siding made from wood, vinyl and fiber cement siding are more durable.

However, because fiber cement can absorb water, your walls may rot. This makes the vinyl more durable in the end. It is flexible enough to be impervious to cracks and chips.

Energy Efficiency

The last thing you may want to consider before making a choice is energy efficiency. Fiber cement siding and vinyl are effective at keeping the elements from doing much harm to your home.

Generally, neither material is a good insulator, but you can get an insulated version of vinyl siding. This lightweight product takes less fuel to move which makes it a more eco-friendly option.

The Choice Is Yours

When it comes to the exterior look of your home, the choice is yours. However, when you consider the difference between fiber cement siding vs. vinyl, you can figure out the right option for you. Protect your home with the proper siding now!

Don’t forget to keep coming back for more articles that can provide you with great tips on your home.